Skip to main content

Property Management Blog


A Day in the Life of a Private Landlord: Does This Sound Like You?

A Day in the Life of a Private Landlord: Does This Sound Like You?

You’re saving the management fee. But have you calculated what managing on your own is actually costing you?

By Pamela McNab-Syvertson, Broker/Owner, Verandah Properties, LLC

An illustrative case study drawn from owner conversations. Identifying details have been omitted; financial examples are hypothetical.

Your phone lights up. Another HOA notice.

The trash cans are visible again. Or a vehicle is parked where it shouldn’t be. You contact the tenant, who promises to handle it. Now you need a photo, another follow-up, and confirmation from the association that the issue is closed.

Meanwhile, a broken window still needs attention. Someone in the household is handy, so perhaps they can take care of it. You live out of state and haven’t recently seen the property yourself.

The rent usually arrives. The tenants have been there for years. You don’t want to upset a relationship that has mostly worked.

So you keep the rent where it is, work around the problems, and tell yourself:

“At least I’m saving the management fee.”

But are you?

When “mostly fine” becomes the management plan

In this case study, an owner has a long-term tenant, rent that has not been regularly reviewed, recurring HOA issues, outstanding repair questions, and household members whose status needs clarification in the rental documents.

The owner wants someone to step in, handle the reminders, perhaps raise the rent a little, and leave the rest of the arrangement intact.

That is understandable. After years of being the person everyone calls, relief sounds appealing.

But reminders alone cannot resolve an arrangement that needs clearer documentation, verified property condition, and consistent expectations.

The important question is bigger than whether this month’s rent arrived:

Is the property being managed in a way that supports its income, condition, and long-term value?

The six-year rent freeze—and the $500 surprise

I know a private landlord who left the rent unchanged for six years and then wanted to increase it by $500 per month to catch up to what he believed was market rent.

Think about that from both sides.

The owner sees years of rising expenses and missed income. The tenant sees a sudden $6,000 increase in annual housing costs.

A market-supported adjustment considered at each renewal can be easier to plan around than years of silence followed by a large jump.

For illustration, suppose an owner increased the monthly rent by $50 at each of six annual renewals, and each new rate remained in place for a full year:

Renewal year

Monthly rent above the original rate

Additional gross rent during that year

1

$50

$600

2

$100

$1,200

3

$150

$1,800

4

$200

$2,400

5

$250

$3,000

6

$300

$3,600

Total over those six full renewal years


$12,600

By the sixth renewal, the monthly rent would be $300 higher. Over the six full years shown, the owner would have collected $12,600 more in gross rent than if rent had stayed flat.

This assumes continuous occupancy, full collection, and market support for every increase. It does not account for expenses or turnover.

It also would not eliminate a $500 gap completely. It would reduce that gap—and avoid leaving the entire adjustment until one difficult conversation.

The lesson is to review rent annually. An increase is not always appropriate: comparable rentals, property condition, tenant retention, vacancy costs, lease terms, and applicable notice requirements all matter.

“Management is expensive.” Compared with what?

Consider a separate illustration:

Monthly comparison

Amount

Current self-managed rent

$1,420

Hypothetical market-supported rent

$1,800

Illustrative management fee at 8%

−$144

Rent remaining after that management fee only

$1,656

Difference from current rent

+$236

That is $2,832 more annually after the illustrated management fee, before other costs.

The $1,800 figure is not a valuation of a particular home. A rental analysis would need to support it. Leasing fees, repairs, vacancy, insurance, taxes, and other expenses must also be considered.

An owner might achieve the same rent through effective self-management. Hiring a manager does not create market value by itself.

But this example exposes the weakness in comparing a management fee with zero. If rent has fallen behind and the owner is still doing all the work, avoiding that fee does not prove the arrangement is saving money.

The costs that never arrive as one neat invoice

Repeated HOA follow-up. A notice means reading the issue, contacting the tenant, verifying correction, documenting it, and closing the loop. When the same issue returns, so does the workload. Clear expectations and consistent, lawful follow-through matter.

Repairs handled informally. A tenant who is handy may mean well. That does not establish whether a particular repair needs a qualified contractor, permits, insurance, or inspection. A promise to fix something is not the same as verified completion.

Unclear household documentation. Who lives in the property? Who signed the lease? Are the records current? These questions deserve review before a disagreement makes them urgent.

Condition assessed from a distance. A reassuring text or a few photos cannot answer every question about the property. Periodic, properly arranged inspections help identify concerns while there is still time to address them.

Decisions driven by discomfort. “They’ve been here so long.” “I hate to bring it up.” “They usually pay.” Those feelings are understandable. They also need to be weighed against the property’s operating needs.

A sound rental budget includes maintenance, vacancy, management, and other operating expenses—not simply the rent received. Fannie Mae’s rental operating-budget guidance makes room for these categories.[1]

A good relationship still needs a clear agreement

You can care about your tenants and run your rental as a business.

You can communicate respectfully and still require compliance with the lease. You can value a long tenancy and still review rent. You can be compassionate without letting necessary repairs become indefinite promises.

Professional management cannot guarantee that a dispute, accident, or insurance claim will never happen. What it can provide is a consistent process for documentation, maintenance, communication, and follow-up.

That structure benefits owners and residents alike.

“My house isn’t fancy enough.”

It does not need to be.

At Verandah, readiness standards concern cleanliness, safety, function, and maintenance. A modest three-bedroom home can meet those standards.

Condition also affects how a home competes. Unresolved repairs can narrow its appeal, affect achievable rent, and make it harder to attract applicants who have other well-maintained options.

A lower rent does not make someone a bad tenant, and a higher rent does not guarantee a good one. Consistent screening and sound management remain essential.

Delaying maintenance can also carry the problem into an eventual sale. The owner may face repairs before listing, buyer requests for concessions, or offers that reflect the work needed.

Sometimes the right next step is a fresh start

Bringing in a manager does not automatically reset an existing tenancy.

At Verandah, we do not take over occupied tenancies like the arrangement described here. Once the residents have vacated and the owner has possession, we can evaluate the home, identify preparation needs, and determine whether it fits our management services.

That creates an opportunity to establish a supported rental price, complete necessary work, and begin a new tenancy with clear expectations.

For an owner who no longer wants to operate a rental, selling may also be worth discussing.

Does this sound like you?

Ask yourself:

  • When did I last review comparable rents?
  • When was the property’s condition last inspected and documented?
  • Are repairs being completed and verified?
  • Do my rental records accurately reflect the household?
  • Am I resolving recurring issues—or repeatedly reminding someone about them?
  • Have I calculated my actual return, including expenses, vacancy, and my time?

Self-management can work when an owner has the time, knowledge, and systems to do it well. But avoiding a management fee is only one line in the calculation.

If you haven’t measured the cost of the arrangement, you haven’t established the savings.

If this sounds familiar, Verandah Properties can help you consider a plan for the home’s next chapter—preparing it for professional management after vacancy or exploring a sale.

Visit VerandahProperties.com to start the conversation.

back